Understanding Judicial Reviews in Scottish Housing Law

If you're a renter in Scotland and you've come up against a housing authority decision—such as eviction, repair delays, or rent increases—you might wonder what your legal rights are. In some cases, you may be able to ask a higher court to review an official decision through a process called a judicial review.
Understanding how judicial reviews work in Scottish housing law can help you protect your rights and make informed choices.

What Is a Judicial Review?

A judicial review is when a court examines whether a public body (like a local council or government department) has acted lawfully in making a decision. This is not the same as an appeal; the court doesn't decide if the decision was right or fair, but rather if the law was followed correctly.

• Common public bodies involved in housing include local councils, the Scottish Housing Regulator, and social landlords.
• Judicial review applies to decisions that affect you, like possession orders, refusal of repairs, or housing allocation issues.

Judicial reviews are handled by the Court of Session in Scotland.

When Might a Renter Use Judicial Review?

If you disagree with a decision made by a local authority or housing association, you might consider a judicial review if:

• The council refuses to offer you homeless accommodation despite meeting the eligibility criteria.
• Your local council has issued an eviction notice based on a process you feel was unfair or did not follow the law.
• There's a failure to repair, and official complaints have not led to action.

Relevant Housing Legislation

• Private Housing (Tenancies) (Scotland) Act 2016: Governs most private tenancies, including eviction and rent increases.
• Housing (Scotland) Act 1987: Sets out councils’ duties for homelessness and repairs.

If you feel your landlord or the council has not followed these laws, judicial review could be an option.

How Does a Judicial Review Work?

Judicial review is a technical legal process. Strict time limits apply—you usually must start the process within three months of the decision. You should:

• Talk to the decision-maker and use any internal complaints or appeals procedures first.
• Seek advice as judicial reviews are managed through the Court of Session and have complex procedures.
• Prepare documents showing how the law was not properly applied (ask for written reasons for the decision).

Key Official Forms for Judicial Review in Scotland

• Form 58.3 – Petition for Judicial Review
  • Use when you want the Court of Session to review a decision by a public body.
  • Example: If your local council refuses your homelessness application, and internal appeals have failed, you would fill out this form to challenge their decision.
  • Find the official form and guidance on the Scottish Courts and Tribunals Service website.
• Request for Reasons
  • Before seeking judicial review, request written reasons for the public body’s decision (there’s usually no official form, but this request should be made in writing).
  • Example: If repairs were refused, ask the council to provide their reasons in writing.
  • See guidance at Scottish Government - How to complain.

Visit the official Scottish Courts and Tribunals Service site for more information about court forms, costs, and guidance for litigants.

The Tribunal for Housing Disputes in Scotland

Before considering judicial review, remember that many private tenancy disputes (like rent increases, eviction notices, or repair claims) should go first to the First-tier Tribunal for Scotland (Housing and Property Chamber).

• This tribunal handles most private landlord-tenant matters under the Private Housing (Tenancies) (Scotland) Act 2016.
• If the tribunal (or a council) makes a legal error, judicial review might be possible at the Court of Session.

How to Begin a Judicial Review

The process is complex and involves specialist court procedures. Here are the typical steps:

• Gather all documents and correspondence related to your housing issue.
• Request written reasons for any decision if you have not already received them.
• Consider free advice services, such as Shelter Scotland, for support and information.
• Complete and submit the Form 58.3 Petition to the Court of Session with a clear explanation of why the decision was unlawful.

For many tenants, going through the Housing and Property Chamber is quicker and less costly than judicial review.

FAQ: Judicial Review and Housing Law for Scottish Renters

1. What is the difference between a tribunal hearing and a judicial review?
   A tribunal hearing (like those held at the Housing and Property Chamber) is where you can challenge a landlord's decision on issues such as eviction, repairs, or rent. A judicial review, on the other hand, asks the Court of Session to check whether a public body or tribunal has correctly followed the law, not to change the actual outcome.
2. Who can apply for judicial review in relation to housing?
   Any renter or tenant who is directly affected by a housing decision made by a public authority in Scotland (like a council or regulator) and who has already tried other complaint procedures may be eligible.
3. Is there a time limit for applying for a judicial review?
   Yes. Applications to the Court of Session must usually be made within three months of the date the disputed decision was made.
4. Can I challenge a private landlord’s action using judicial review?
   No. Judicial reviews only apply to public or governmental bodies, not to decisions of private individuals. Most disputes with private landlords should go to the Housing and Property Chamber instead.
5. Will I need legal help to apply for a judicial review?
   Given the complexity and strict court procedures, it is strongly recommended to seek advice from a solicitor or a specialist housing adviser before considering judicial review in Scotland.

Conclusion: Key Takeaways

• Judicial review lets Scottish renters challenge public authority decisions—primarily over procedure and legality, not fairness of the outcome.
• Many disputes are resolved through the Housing and Property Chamber, not judicial review.
• There are strict time limits and forms, such as Form 58.3, so get support early and act quickly if you wish to challenge a council or public body’s housing decision.

A little preparation and the right advice go a long way—don’t hesitate to reach out to qualified sources if you’re unsure about your legal options.

Need Help? Resources for Renters

• Shelter Scotland – Expert housing advice and support for renters.
• Citizens Advice Scotland – Free and confidential advice helplines and local offices.
• First-tier Tribunal for Scotland (Housing and Property Chamber) – Tenant dispute resolution and application guidance.
• Court of Session – Official guidance on judicial review procedures in Scotland.

---

1. Private Housing (Tenancies) (Scotland) Act 2016
2. Housing (Scotland) Act 1987
3. Court of Session – Judicial Review Procedures
4. First-tier Tribunal for Scotland (Housing and Property Chamber)
5. Court of Session Forms and Rules
6. Scottish Government – How to Complain

Categories

Tenant Rights & Responsibilities Rent, Deposits & Increases Tenancy Types & Agreements Moving In & Out Procedures Repairs, Maintenance & Housing Standards Eviction Notices & Repossessions Shared Housing, HMOs & Lodgers Discrimination, Harassment & Accessibility Utilities, Bills & Council Tax Affordable Housing, Social Housing & Benefits Dispute Resolution & Housing Tribunals Health, Safety & Fire Regulations Privacy, Landlord Entry & Surveillance Unusual & Special Tenancy Situations Renters’ Insurance & Liability Homelessness Support & Post-Eviction Help Landlord Duties, Licensing & Penalties Housing Law, Legal Updates & Case Studies Mental Health, Disability & Vulnerable Renters’ Rights Rent Repayment Orders & Compensation